Review: Eliza Carthy and Ben Seal- Through That Sound (My Secret Was Made Known)


Image: Kirsty Whiten

Eliza Carthy and Ben Seal’s Through That Sound (My Secret Was Made Known) marks a departure from Carthy’s more traditional folk sound for which she’s best known, into more experimental forays.

Seal’s influence is all over this. The Fife based producer, composer and musician steers a gorgeous, sometimes unsettling electronic wave, buffeting the songs from the throbbing Ships Passing to the emotionally raw tribute to Carthy’s late Aunt Lal in The Black Queen. 

The band are terrific (also featuring Willy Molleson, Phil Alexander and Pete Furniss) and Carthy’s gorgeous voice is like a robust red wine- this much we’ve always known-  but the new jazz direction suits her fine. Mean To Me and Until Then (The Goodnight Song)  are torch songs for the twenty first century, with the former a slinky sort of duet with Seal and the latter a brooding, sweeping epic  with a cinematic sheen.

Strings are like sinews on  Mr McFall’s Chamber; Our Savage Friends has a bruised lyrical intensity and vulnerability like a shared secret.



Coming on as a twenty first century Lotte Lenya for lockdown,  she’s like a siren with good- if often mischievous- intentions.  Drink long and deep, and let these siren songs guide you, from choppy waters in uncertain times to the safety and comfort of dry land.

Out now via Hem Hem Records.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s